Friday, August 21, 2009

I AM NOT IN LOVE WITH EDWARD

Yes, I am talking about the sweet talking, blood sucking, piano playing vampire from Twilight, Edward.

I am not in love with him, which appears to make me stand out against millions of girls around the world. And this is a fact that concerns me.

Yes, he's hot. We get it. He's hot, and he's utterly and irreversibly in love with Bella. But is love enough? I say no. I have nothing against love, and passionate love at that, but when it becomes an excuse for inexcusable behaviour there is a problem. He is controlling beyond reason. He tells her what to do, where she can go, and who she can be friends with. And because she loves him, she lets him control her. He even kidnaps her a couple of times, forcing her to be where he thinks she ought to be. All under the guise of keeping her safe. I do not doubt the lovely motives, but does that really make it ok? I say absolutely not!

This perfect ideal of Edward sets up a whole generation of young girls to get in abusive, controlling relationships. If he loves me, it's ok. He controls me because he cares. Then it's a slippery slope, from control to abuse. I'm not saying all controlling guys end up abusing their girlfriends/wives, but it lends itself to going in that direction.

Yes Edward never hurts her physically, but does that make it ok? Not in my book. Not that I have a book... you get my point though.

Love is not an excuse for poor behaviour. Controlling relationships are not ok and should not be set up as an over-romanticised ideal. Bella constantly gets mad at Edward, then forgives him as soon as she sees him coz he's so hot and she loves him! That is not ok! Girls need to be taught to respect themselves and expect men to respect them too, not offer up excuses for why they are not being respected.

7 Comments:

  1. Litha said...
    Twilight: Meh
    Ludicrousity said...
    Yes Lisa! Another good point, the books aren't even that good.
    Luke said...
    You're not being rational, sis. Sounds like you need a nice, controlling boyfriend to stop you saying silly things.

    I know this really hot guy you might like. He likes long walks on the beach, but he really hates daylight.

    Get back to me and I'll hook you up.
    Ludicrousity said...
    I hate you.
    Anonymous said...
    hey megan, it's jo chesson here, an old-school ex-eltham baptistite. was just wondering if you could help me, kathryn toohey said you could direct me to some eltham baptist videos of night service sermons given by stewy hunt a little while ago? if you can help please email me joannechesson@gmail.com, thatd be great!
    Lance said...
    "Love is not an excuse for poor behaviour". I would argue that from what you're describing that it is not love at all. If you match up this guy's behaviour against Paul's famous statement in 1Corinthians 13 "Love is patient...", it is clear that it is not love at all.

    It is alarming that a whole generation of girls will be exposed to this show and see this sort of behaviour as normative, or at least acceptable. Not good at all.
    Ludicrousity said...
    I agree Lance.
    I would still say he loves her, but in the emotional sense, not in the Biblical definition of love, or in any common sense version of love in my opinion!

Post a Comment



Template by:
Free Blog Templates